登陆注册
34578700000047

第47章 On Smart Novelists and the Smart Set(1)

In one sense, at any rate, it is more valuable to read bad literature than good literature. Good literature may tell us the mind of one man; but bad literature may tell us the mind of many men.

A good novel tells us the truth about its hero; but a bad novel tells us the truth about its author. It does much more than that, it tells us the truth about its readers; and, oddly enough, it tells us this all the more the more cynical and immoral be the motive of its manufacture. The more dishonest a book is as a book the more honest it is as a public document.

A sincere novel exhibits the simplicity of one particular man;an insincere novel exhibits the simplicity of mankind.

The pedantic decisions and definable readjustments of man may be found in scrolls and statute books and scriptures;but men's basic assumptions and everlasting energies are to be found in penny dreadfuls and halfpenny novelettes. Thus a man, like many men of real culture in our day, might learn from good literature nothing except the power to appreciate good literature.

But from bad literature he might learn to govern empires and look over the map of mankind.

There is one rather interesting example of this state of things in which the weaker literature is really the stronger and the stronger the weaker. It is the case of what may be called, for the sake of an approximate description, the literature of aristocracy;or, if you prefer the description, the literature of snobbishness.

Now if any one wishes to find a really effective and comprehensible and permanent case for aristocracy well and sincerely stated, let him read, not the modern philosophical conservatives, not even Nietzsche, let him read the Bow Bells Novelettes.

Of the case of Nietzsche I am confessedly more doubtful.

Nietzsche and the Bow Bells Novelettes have both obviously the same fundamental character; they both worship the tall man with curling moustaches and herculean bodily power, and they both worship him in a manner which is somewhat feminine and hysterical.

Even here, however, the Novelette easily maintains its philosophical superiority, because it does attribute to the strong man those virtues which do commonly belong to him, such virtues as laziness and kindliness and a rather reckless benevolence, and a great dislike of hurting the weak. Nietzsche, on the other hand, attributes to the strong man that scorn against weakness which only exists among invalids. It is not, however, of the secondary merits of the great German philosopher, but of the primary merits of the Bow Bells Novelettes, that it is my present affair to speak.

The picture of aristocracy in the popular sentimental novelette seems to me very satisfactory as a permanent political and philosophical guide.

It may be inaccurate about details such as the title by which a baronet is addressed or the width of a mountain chasm which a baronet can conveniently leap, but it is not a bad description of the general idea and intention of aristocracy as they exist in human affairs.

The essential dream of aristocracy is magnificence and valour;and if the Family Herald Supplement sometimes distorts or exaggerates these things, at least, it does not fall short in them.

It never errs by ****** the mountain chasm too narrow or the title of the baronet insufficiently impressive. But above this sane reliable old literature of snobbishness there has arisen in our time another kind of literature of snobbishness which, with its much higher pretensions, seems to me worthy of very much less respect. Incidentally (if that matters), it is much better literature. But it is immeasurably worse philosophy, immeasurably worse ethics and politics, immeasurably worse vital rendering of aristocracy and humanity as they really are.

From such books as those of which I wish now to speak we can discover what a clever man can do with the idea of aristocracy.

But from the Family Herald Supplement literature we can learn what the idea of aristocracy can do with a man who is not clever.

And when we know that we know English history.

This new aristocratic fiction must have caught the attention of everybody who has read the best fiction for the last fifteen years.

It is that genuine or alleged literature of the Smart Set which represents that set as distinguished, not only by smart dresses, but by smart sayings. To the bad baronet, to the good baronet, to the romantic and misunderstood baronet who is supposed to be a bad baronet, but is a good baronet, this school has added a conception undreamed of in the former years--the conception of an amusing baronet.

The aristocrat is not merely to be taller than mortal men and stronger and handsomer, he is also to be more witty.

He is the long man with the short epigram. Many eminent, and deservedly eminent, modern novelists must accept some responsibility for having supported this worst form of snobbishness--an intellectual snobbishness. The talented author of "Dodo" is responsible for having in some sense created the fashion as a fashion.

Mr. Hichens, in the "Green Carnation," reaffirmed the strange idea that young noblemen talk well; though his case had some vague biographical foundation, and in consequence an excuse. Mrs. Craigie is considerably guilty in the matter, although, or rather because, she has combined the aristocratic note with a note of some moral and even religious sincerity. When you are saving a man's soul, even in a novel, it is indecent to mention that he is a gentleman.

Nor can blame in this matter be altogether removed from a man of much greater ability, and a man who has proved his possession of the highest of human instinct, the romantic instinct--I mean Mr. Anthony Hope.

In a galloping, impossible melodrama like "The Prisoner of Zenda,"the blood of kings fanned an excellent fantastic thread or theme.

But the blood of kings is not a thing that can be taken seriously.

同类推荐
  • 神相铁关刀

    神相铁关刀

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 咏袜

    咏袜

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 台海使槎录

    台海使槎录

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 孔子诗论

    孔子诗论

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 杂纂三续

    杂纂三续

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 一号通缉令

    一号通缉令

    陈玉福先生辛勤创作、寒暑不辍,在其二十七年的创作生涯中,发表、出版了五百万字的作品。中国作家网、搜狐、新浪及《南京日报》、《贵阳晚报》、《兰州晨报》等五十余家海内外报刊连载过他的作品,反响强烈。他写故事曲折跌宕,时有妙笔,惊心动魄,荡气回肠;塑造人物善于从侧面取势,大处着眼,细微处着墨,各色人物跃然纸上,历历如在眼前。因此,他的作品大多脍炙人口,让人爱不释卷。“1号”系列长篇中,有三部登上了全国百家书城十大畅销书排行榜。
  • 通往勃兰的宫桥

    通往勃兰的宫桥

    是挣扎,是抗争,为自由的奔放,为了自己的未来而努力争取。亦是内心中一切惶寂的救赎。是什么样的人!是什么样的人才可以将这让人用一生去追求的东西以这种别样的形式演奏出来?还是如此得淋漓尽致。幻世一般的浮华在风中摇曳,亦在风中飘零。如掌间无处捉摸的细碎,心性的起伏不定似乎都在这一刻沉静了下来。
  • 超级父母VS绝对宝贝——营养美食

    超级父母VS绝对宝贝——营养美食

    0~6岁孩子的“吃喝拉撒”究竟该怎么对付?孩子生病了,我该怎样护理?早期教育要做还是不做或者怎么做?精养、散养、放养、慢养,孩子到底该怎么养?小生命降临了,除了初为人父、为人母的喜悦外,每位父母都会产生不知所措的感觉,尤其是80后的父母自己都还是未长大的孩子呢。《超级父母VS绝对宝贝营养美食》精选国内外多个家庭的育儿故事,针对孩子成长期的各个可能性,提供父母有效的解决办法。本书分享育儿父母精心对待孩子每一餐的营养美食经验。
  • 郡主请手下留情

    郡主请手下留情

    能吃能睡的影后摇身一变却成为牙牙学语的小婴儿,好不容易成为能文能武的郡主大人却深陷一场乱世斗争,本以为是个养成实际上却是个权游,内心无比憋屈的她又将掀起怎样的风浪?内涵沙雕日常,结局开放。
  • 念安一生

    念安一生

    她,江湖人人惧怕,无人敢惹;他,寂寂无名,但背后却隐藏多重身份。当她遇见他,会发生什么变化?请支持正版作品,切勿侵权。如果喜欢,请支持,我将尽我所能为大家提供优质内容;不喜勿喷~么么~
  • 庄氏史案

    庄氏史案

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 神奇宝贝之喧闹

    神奇宝贝之喧闹

    第一:绝不收服皮卡丘第二:绝不收服笨笨鱼第三:绝不收服卡比兽没错我就是蜻蜓队·····阿不萌萌的少年
  • 浅笑谁与争

    浅笑谁与争

    她们不是姐妹胜似姐妹生命消逝的最后一刻只有一句“来世我们还是战友”穿越重生竟真成了双胞胎姐妹可是......预言之中的孩子终于出现,会在这个世界掀起怎样的波澜?他们期待已久的双胞胎,真实身份经然是....且看两姐妹如何在异世界逆天而行,创造属于她们的奇迹。两人的情感又能否经历住世事的考验,遵守当初的誓言?喜欢本文的读者可以收藏哦~
  • 开着外挂的嚣张人生

    开着外挂的嚣张人生

    一个神奇的外挂,成就的一部人生传奇……
  • 进化国度

    进化国度

    一觉醒来,世界变成行尸走肉的世界。身份成迷,爱人成谜,洪励安身边的一切一天之内崩塌。