登陆注册
34578700000007

第7章 On the negative spirit(3)

We are fond of talking about "education"; that is a dodge to avoid discussing what is good. The modern man says, "Let us leave all these arbitrary standards and embrace liberty."This is, logically rendered, "Let us not decide what is good, but let it be considered good not to decide it." He says, "Away with your old moral formulae; I am for progress."This, logically stated, means, "Let us not settle what is good;but let us settle whether we are getting more of it."He says, "Neither in religion nor morality, my friend, lie the hopes of the race, but in education." This, clearly expressed, means, "We cannot decide what is good, but let us give it to our children."Mr. H.G. Wells, that exceedingly clear-sighted man, has pointed out in a recent work that this has happened in connection with economic questions.

The old economists, he says, made generalizations, and they were (in Mr. Wells's view) mostly wrong. But the new economists, he says, seem to have lost the power of ****** any generalizations at all.

And they cover this incapacity with a general claim to be, in specific cases, regarded as "experts", a claim "proper enough in a hairdresser or a fashionable physician, but indecent in a philosopher or a man of science."But in spite of the refreshing rationality with which Mr. Wells has indicated this, it must also be said that he himself has fallen into the same enormous modern error. In the opening pages of that excellent book MANKIND IN THE MAKING, he dismisses the ideals of art, religion, abstract morality, and the rest, and says that he is going to consider men in their chief function, the function of parenthood.

He is going to discuss life as a "tissue of births." He is not going to ask what will produce satisfactory saints or satisfactory heroes, but what will produce satisfactory fathers and mothers. The whole is set forward so sensibly that it is a few moments at least before the reader realises that it is another example of unconscious shirking. What is the good of begetting a man until we have settled what is the good of being a man?

You are merely handing on to him a problem you dare not settle yourself.

It is as if a man were asked, "What is the use of a hammer?" and answered, "To make hammers"; and when asked, "And of those hammers, what is the use?" answered, "To make hammers again". Just as such a man would be perpetually putting off the question of the ultimate use of carpentry, so Mr. Wells and all the rest of us are by these phrases successfully putting off the question of the ultimate value of the human life.

The case of the general talk of "progress" is, indeed, an extreme one. As enunciated today, "progress" is simply a comparative of which we have not settled the superlative.

We meet every ideal of religion, patriotism, beauty, or brute pleasure with the alternative ideal of progress--that is to say, we meet every proposal of getting something that we know about, with an alternative proposal of getting a great deal more of nobody knows what. Progress, properly understood, has, indeed, a most dignified and legitimate meaning. But as used in opposition to precise moral ideals, it is ludicrous. So far from it being the truth that the ideal of progress is to be set against that of ethical or religious finality, the reverse is the truth.

Nobody has any business to use the word "progress" unless he has a definite creed and a cast-iron code of morals.

Nobody can be progressive without being doctrinal; I might almost say that nobody can be progressive without being infallible --at any rate, without believing in some infallibility.

For progress by its very name indicates a direction;and the moment we are in the least doubtful about the direction, we become in the same degree doubtful about the progress.

Never perhaps since the beginning of the world has there been an age that had less right to use the word "progress" than we.

In the Catholic twelfth century, in the philosophic eighteenth century, the direction may have been a good or a bad one, men may have differed more or less about how far they went, and in what direction, but about the direction they did in the main agree, and consequently they had the genuine sensation of progress.

But it is precisely about the direction that we disagree.

Whether the future excellence lies in more law or less law, in more liberty or less liberty; whether property will be finally concentrated or finally cut up; whether sexual passion will reach its sanest in an almost virgin intellectualism or in a full animal *******; whether we should love everybody with Tolstoy, or spare nobody with Nietzsche;--these are the things about which we are actually fighting most. It is not merely true that the age which has settled least what is progress is this "progressive" age.

It is, moreover, true that the people who have settled least what is progress are the most "progressive" people in it.

The ordinary mass, the men who have never troubled about progress, might be trusted perhaps to progress. The particular individuals who talk about progress would certainly fly to the four winds of heaven when the pistol-shot started the race.

I do not, therefore, say that the word "progress" is unmeaning; I say it is unmeaning without the previous definition of a moral doctrine, and that it can only be applied to groups of persons who hold that doctrine in common. Progress is not an illegitimate word, but it is logically evident that it is illegitimate for us.

It is a sacred word, a word which could only rightly be used by rigid believers and in the ages of faith.

同类推荐
  • People Out of Time

    People Out of Time

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 长门怨

    长门怨

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 窦存

    窦存

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • Black Beauty

    Black Beauty

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
  • 小亨集

    小亨集

    本书为公版书,为不受著作权法限制的作家、艺术家及其它人士发布的作品,供广大读者阅读交流。
热门推荐
  • 第八魄之谢子令

    第八魄之谢子令

    荒芜凶险的遗弃世界,生世成谜的少年,神秘莫测的血石,且看少年如何开展一段又一段惊险之旅的。......天地有正气,杂然赋流形。这是一个讲正义的故事。
  • 天行

    天行

    号称“北辰骑神”的天才玩家以自创的“牧马冲锋流”战术击败了国服第一弓手北冥雪,被誉为天纵战榜第一骑士的他,却受到小人排挤,最终离开了效力已久的银狐俱乐部。是沉沦,还是再次崛起?恰逢其时,月恒集团第四款游戏“天行”正式上线,虚拟世界再起风云!
  • 逆天弃少

    逆天弃少

    一位穷学生,意外得到了特工秘密,在连串奇遇中,渐渐成长为身手高强的绝世高手。他的身世背后,隐藏着一段滔天大仇;学校一场股神比赛,竟然是国际金融巨鳄间的血腥角逐。这是个曲折离奇的都市故事,更是场面惊人、荡气回肠的复仇之歌!
  • 快穿之我只爱你

    快穿之我只爱你

    简介:秋唯风:系统?那是什么鬼?别开玩笑了。喵咪:呜呜~秋秋,嗝,泥,你不要偶了吗?呜呜…唐渝庭:【冷笑】我家唯唯什么时候要过你了?!还有,别叫那么亲密!秋唯风:……=_=结局he,微人妻淡泊受VS占有欲极强攻目前确定世界:校园—兄弟—末世—喵等喵作者:哇嘎嘎!本书乃喵喵新书,望支持!学生党,只能周末更新喵喵!作者脑洞特大,雷者误入。
  • 诸天莽帝

    诸天莽帝

    你穿越到一拳世界,抽奖获得“认真一拳”;你穿越到漫威世界,抽奖获得“钢铁战衣”;你穿越到火影世界,抽奖获得“轮回写轮眼”;……现在,问题来了,获得众多逆天神技、神器的你,不断被人上门挑衅,还能忍得住100天不用吗?对此,陆莽只有一个答案:忍什么啊!
  • 天行

    天行

    号称“北辰骑神”的天才玩家以自创的“牧马冲锋流”战术击败了国服第一弓手北冥雪,被誉为天纵战榜第一骑士的他,却受到小人排挤,最终离开了效力已久的银狐俱乐部。是沉沦,还是再次崛起?恰逢其时,月恒集团第四款游戏“天行”正式上线,虚拟世界再起风云!
  • 泷崎宫

    泷崎宫

    峙神夫人从三途河取来的并蒂曼珠,经过三百年培育,终于养育出一对背生双翼的孪生姐妹,姐姐优雅知性,美名远播,妹妹古灵精怪,恶名在外。前世妹妹阴差阳错,嫁给了姐姐的爱人,同根同源的姐妹,转眼了成仇人。转世投胎,几人再续前缘,然而,相亲相爱的姐妹,多年之后,忆起前世,又该如何面对现实?
  • 旧世圣约

    旧世圣约

    魔王,邪恶与恐惧的代名词,魔王和龙一样强大,但是总是被自称正义的勇者打败,世间轮回即是如此~他被败亡的上代魔王召唤至此,一觉醒来成为了新的魔王。带着地球的知识,他让自己成为了一个与众不同的魔王,并打算在圣魔帝国的废墟上重新建立起一个伟大的帝国!
  • 天行

    天行

    号称“北辰骑神”的天才玩家以自创的“牧马冲锋流”战术击败了国服第一弓手北冥雪,被誉为天纵战榜第一骑士的他,却受到小人排挤,最终离开了效力已久的银狐俱乐部。是沉沦,还是再次崛起?恰逢其时,月恒集团第四款游戏“天行”正式上线,虚拟世界再起风云!
  • 楚城之半世浮华

    楚城之半世浮华

    她是一个寄存在别人身体里的灵魂,忘记了过往,被人认为是双重人格;她一直在寻找回去的路,直到遇见他,他能一眼看出她的灵魂……从此她走上了一条不归路……